Saturday, March 18, 2023


“We share a standard mission to advertise transparency in authorities.”

American Oversight, in its quite a few EMails to the Florida Division of Training, beginning on Could 4, 2022.

Tallahasee_supreme_court_920 Inside Florida .org(The Florida Supreme Courtroom / 920 Inside Florida)

American Oversight is a nonprofit group that made greater than eight (8) requests for public entry to non-exempt public information held by the Florida Division of Training.  They made extra requests than that, however they sued the DOE for not complying with respect to these 8 below the Florida Structure and Florida’s Public Information Act.  Right here is their grievance:  Obtain American Oversight v. Florida Dep’t of Training Grievance to Implement Public Information Act filed March 16 2023 (second Jud. Cir. Leon County Fla.).

American Oversight’s public information requests are hooked up as Displays to their Grievance and you’ll learn them for your self.

They acquired fed up, apparently, and complained about DOE’s enterprise mannequin of “a demonstrated historical past of delayed responses to American Oversight’s public information requests.”  Id. at 6 n.7.  So that they sued for higher entry, or in lots of instances entry within the first place, to the general public information they requested on Could 4, 2022; January 12, 2023, and February 15, 2023.  They despatched observe up EMails on their earlier requests on January 25, 2023 and acquired crickets, nothing, Nada, Radio Silence from the present Florida Division of Training.  Lastly, they repeated their public information requests (and will have added some) once they despatched their public information request on February 15, 2023.  “So far, DOE has failed to supply a single file that’s conscious of any of the eight requests at subject on this Grievance.”  Id. at 20, ¶ 5.

No matter how the American Oversight v. Fla. Dep’t of Training lawsuit seems, in a choice cited within the Grievance (id. at 20), the Florida Supreme Courtroom beforehand held:

The one problem permitted by the Act on the time a request for information is made is the assertion of a statutory exemption pursuant to part 119.07.  The one individual with the facility to boost such a problem is the custodian. 

Tribune Co. v. Cannella, 458 So. second 1075, 1078-79 (Fla. 1984).  There may be after all no statutory exemption pursuant to part 119.07 right here, parenthetically, and naturally there was no problem right here, allegedly simply delay and silence and incomplete responses.

Additional, the legislation has been clear for practically 40 years, at the least till the 2023 Florida DOE got here alongside, that it’s as much as the Florida Legislature to exempt information from public disclosure, not the DOE (or anybody else):

The legislature has positioned the books on the desk; solely it has the facility to change that state of affairs.

    We subsequently maintain that the legislative scheme of the Public Information Act has preempted the legislation regarding any delay in producing information for inspection. The one delay permitted by the Act is the restricted cheap time allowed the custodian to retrieve the file and delete these parts of the file the custodian asserts are exempt.

Tribune Co., 458 So. second at 1079 (emphasis added).

Once more, no matter how the American Oversight v. Fla. Dep’t of Training case could also be determined, there’s a query for Florida’s chief legislation enforcement officer, the Lawyer Common of the State of Florida:  Is the Florida Supreme Courtroom’s determination nonetheless the legislation of Florida?  Or in your judgment, Common Ashley Moody, does the Florida DOE — or anybody else — now have the facility to change that state of affairs?

On this final day of Sunshine Week, this text will likely be revealed each on Claims and Points Weblog and on Claims and Unhealthy Religion Regulation Weblog.

Please learn the disclaimer.  ©2023 Dennis J. Wall.  All rights reserved.



Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Most Popular

Recent Comments